Egyptian security forces stand guard on December 2, 2013 outside the criminal court in Egypt's northern coastal city of Alexandria
Egyptian security forces stand guard on December 2, 2013 outside the criminal court in Egypt's northern coastal city of Alexandria © - AFP/File
Egyptian security forces stand guard on December 2, 2013 outside the criminal court in Egypt's northern coastal city of Alexandria
AFP
Last updated: December 5, 2013

US urged to tighten message on human rights abuses

Banner Icon

Human rights activists Wednesday urged the US government to be more consistent in its approach toward repressive regimes, warning that muddled responses sent the wrong message to democracy campaigners.

America's over-arching focus on security concerns and the fight against terrorism is obscuring the need to hold governments accountable for rights abuses, activists said at the start of a two-day seminar organized by the Washington-based group Human Rights First.

The message was particularly confused in Egypt, where the US has frozen part of its aid to the military, and put on hold the delivery of large weapons systems, after it ousted president Mohamed Morsi in July, said activist Nadine Wahab.

"When funding... continues to go to the weapons that attack and create human rights violations, like tear gas and bullets, but you hold the F-16s, the message that's going to these governments and going to human rights defenders is that human rights is not important," said Wahab, an expert with the Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies.

And she challenged the US administration's policy of not cutting off all military aid to Egypt, which was aimed at helping the Egyptian army to battle militants in the Sinai peninsula and help maintain regional stability.

"One of the things that the United States really needs to do is look at its counter-terrorism narrative, look at how security is thought of within a domestic policy and an international policy and see whether security and stability is human rights? Or whether security and stability is guns and more weapons?" said Wahab.

UN special rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly, Maina Kiai, agreed saying the United States needed to treat all governments the same way.

"It's very difficult to understand why the US government treats Ethiopia when it attacks human rights defenders differently from how the US treats Zimbabwe. Or how the US treats Egypt as opposed to Bahrain," he said.

"Once you start seeing these differences they start sending a message across the world that actually the US wants to pick and choose where it wants to defend human rights."

Ethiopia is one of the largest recipients of US aid in Africa, yet in 2009 it passed a law on non-government organizations which activists slammed as a bid by the government -- in power for 21 years -- to wipe out any civil society.

The legislation has largely passed without comment and US Secretary of State John Kerry made a high-profile visit to the country in May to attend an African Union summit.

The "US supporting a despotic government like the Ethiopian government is essentially creating destabilization in the Horn of Africa and Ethiopia," warned Yalemzewd Bekele Mulat, an Ethiopian lawyer and activist.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Stay Connected
twitter icon Twitter 13,558 linkedin icon LinkedIn 463
facebook icon Facebook 87,173 google+ icon Google+ 272