Supporters of Egyptian presidential candidate Abdel Fattah al-Sisi wave flags as they celebrate in a street in Cairo on May 28, 2014
Supporters of Egyptian presidential candidate Abdel Fattah al-Sisi wave flags as they celebrate in a street in Cairo on May 28, 2014 © Khaled Desouki - AFP/File
Supporters of Egyptian presidential candidate Abdel Fattah al-Sisi wave flags as they celebrate in a street in Cairo on May 28, 2014
<
>
Sarah Benhaida
Last updated: May 30, 2014

Sisi's election win was never doubted, but Egypt's democracy is questioned

Banner Icon

The election of ex-army chief Abdel Fattah al-Sisi as Egypt's president was never in doubt, with only a token challenger and the banned Muslim Brotherhood and liberal youth groups boycotting the vote.

Preliminary results from this week's two-day election, that was extended to three days because of low turnout, gave 96 percent of votes to the retired field marshal who ousted Islamist president Mohamed Morsi last July.

Hamdeen Sabbahi, who won less than four percent, was criticised for taking part in what rights activists and political analysts say was a "cosmetic" election to rubber stamp Sisi's formal accession to power.

The election was boycotted not only by the Brotherhood of Morsi, Egypt's first civilian and freely elected president, it was also shunned by the April 6 youth group that spearheaded the 2011 uprising that toppled Hosni Mubarak.

Their absence was a major contributing factor in Sisi failing to get the sweeping endorsement hoped for to put a stamp of legitimacy on Morsi's ouster and the subsequent bloody crackdown on the Brotherhood.

Indeed, after voting was extended for a day, authorities put turnout at about 25 million people, or 47 percent, down from nearly 52 percent when Morsi was elected in 2012.

Both the Brotherhood and April 6, who are at opposite ends of the political spectrum, have been blacklisted by the authorities.

The Big Pharaoh, a well-known blogger, said on Twitter that the winners of the election were "1-People who didn't vote 2-Mr. Sisi. 3- Mr. Invalid Ballots 4- Mr. Sabbahi."

Mona Seif, a founding member of "No to Military Trials for Civilians," one of Egypt's most active youth groups, cast doubts on the "legend of massive participation" and criticised "two days of hysteria" as television anchors alternated insults, supplications and threats to get Egyptians to vote.

A European Union team that observed the election regretted Thursday the lack of participation of some "stakeholders," a likely reference to the Brotherhood and youthful dissidents.

It also said "private media provided candidate (Sisi) with more than twice the coverage provided to candidate Sabbahi."

"Stakeholders opposed to the roadmap received no media coverage," it added.

Since Morsi's ouster, Sisi has been hailed as a hero and a saviour by the overwhelming majority of private media.

While interviewing the retired field marshal ahead of the election, many television anchors openly expressed their admiration for him, even as he remained vague about his electoral programme, arguing that it should be kept secret for national security reasons.

"Field marshal with no war, candidate with no programme, president with no election", opposition group Askar Kazibun (Military are liars in Arabic) wrote on Twitter.

- Fairness of elections 'undermined' -

The authorities are touting the election as a milestone on the road to democracy following Morsi's ouster, but Human Rights Watch said the state crackdown "stripped these elections of real meaning."

At least 1,400 Morsi supporters have died in street clashes and more than 15,000 others been jailed since the crackdown began in August.

On top of that, dozens of young activists have been jailed for violating a law banning all but police-authorised protests.

"The intense crackdown on dissent over the last 10 months has created a repressive environment that severely undermines the fairness of the elections," HRW said.

Rights advocates have also criticised the decision to extend voting as raising questions about the democratic credentials of the election and even questioned the authorities' skills.

"By changing the rules at the last moment, the (electoral) commission took a political decision that raised many doubts" regarding the election's democratic nature, Adel Ramadan, from the Egyptian Initiative for Personal rights, told AFP.

And Middle East expert Karim Bitar said "not only did the new authorities show their lack of desire for democracy, they also proved to be very incompetent in the organisation of the process, which is a bad omen for the future."

In 2012, in the presidential election organised after Mubarak's overthrow, Morsi secured around 13 million vote in a run-off against Ahmed Shafiq, Mubarak's last premier.

Ahmed Samih, head of the Andalus Institute for Tolerance, wonders ironically where Sisi got all his votes.

"Sisi's campaign claim that he secured 23 million votes. In 2012, the two candidates of the second round, gathered together 26 million voices. But this year the Muslim Brotherhood are boycotting. Where did all these votes come from?"

blog comments powered by Disqus